Adjustment
issues among Adolescents of Substance Using Parents.
Mrs. Sukhbir Kaur1*, Dr.
(Mrs) Triza Jiwan2
1Ph.D
Nursing Scholar, Lecturer, Department of Psychiatric Nursing, Sri Guru Ramdas
College of Nursing, G.R.D Medical Institute of Sciences and Research, Amrisar,
Punjab.
2Professor
and Principal, Department of Psychiatric Nursing, Kular College of Nursing,
Bija, Ludhiana, Punjab.
*Corresponding Author Email: sukh.jaura@yahoo.in
ABSTRACT:
Adolescence is the most
important period of human life which is called the transitional period of life.
Adolescence is also a period of progress towards mental, intellectual and
emotional maturation. It is estimated that six to nine million children and
adolescents in the United States have mental or behavioral problems. Indian
Council of Medical Research reported that about 12.8 per cent of children (1-16
years) suffer from mental health problems. With respect to adolescent
adjustment, parental warmth/involvement and behavioral control are associated
with greater social competence, autonomy, positive attitudes toward school and
work, academic achievement and self-esteem, as well as with less depression, school
misconduct, delinquency and drug use. There is strong evidence to suggest that
family dysfunction during childhood can negatively influence later life
experiences and adjustment. Drinking behavior may interrupt normal family
tasks, cause conflict and demand adjustive and adaptive responses from family
members who do not know how to appropriately respond. Parental alcohol abuse is
an independent risk factor for attention and conduct problems at school, which
is not fully mediated by adolescent mental distress. Prior research has found
that characteristics of the family (e.g., parental monitoring, parental
discipline, family conflict, family rituals) may mediate and/or moderate the
relationship between parental alcoholism and offspring adjustment. The Longitudinal
associations between fathers' heavy drinking patterns and children's
psychosocial adjustment results demonstrated significant and meaningful
associations between these drink patterns in fathers and adjustment problems in
children over time. It is therefore important that the therapeutic needs of
these children are addressed through individual psychotherapy and other
supportive therapies by providing an opportunity for ventilation of feelings
and integrating elements that will boost their self esteem and promote their
psychosocial adjustment in deficient areas. Normal difficulties and dilemmas
associated with adolescence in general could be worked through in these
sessions besides focusing on issues pertaining to parental alcoholism.
Intervention with children of alcoholics or substance users, must hence involve
resolution of individualized issues pertaining to adolescence as well as
parental alcoholism. Elements to enhance their self esteem and adjustment
across various domains need to be consciously included besides involving them
in family therapy sessions.
KEYWORDS:.
Adolescents, Adjustment, Interventions, Parental Substance Use.
INTRODUCTION:
Adolescence is the most
important period of human life which is called the transitional period of
life. It is during adolescence that
rapid physical growth and changes in physiological processes take place.
Adolescence is also a period of progress towards mental, intellectual and
emotional maturation.. The interaction of adolescent with the existing
socio-cultural milieu results in some new developments. It initiates a process
of redefining their social relationships. Society generally does not define a
distinctively definite role for adolescents. And hence, they are caught in the
ambiguous overlap between the categorically defined roles of childhood and
adulthood. Their psychological needs also are not appreciated in proper
perspective by the society. This at times generates among them aggressive and
reactionary behavior which many a time is socially disapproved. So, they need
proper guidance to fulfill their emotional, social and educational needs.
(Gehlawat, 2009)1
Adolescents account for
about 1/5th of India’s population (Anon, 2004)2.Recent researches
suggest that more young people are beginning to report of mental health
problems, as they perceive more stress. It is estimated that six to nine
million children and adolescents in the United States have mental or behavioral
problems. Indian Council of Medical Research reported that about 12.8 per cent
of children (1-16 years) suffer from mental health problems. According to
findings 69.56 per cent of adolescents had suicidal behavior due to
parent-child problems, about 17.39 per cent due to partner relational problems,
8.69 per cent due to adjustment disorders and 4.35 per cent of children due to
depression. Adolescents in disadvantaged communities are at elevated risk for
exposure to multiple stressors, indicating high rates of crime and
victimization, family poverty, family conflict, increased prevalence of deviant
peers and school with inadequate resources (Gonzales et al., 2001)3.
Adjustment in adolescence:
Duncan (1949)4
defined adjustment as a means of state of harmonious relationship between a
person and his environment. It also refers to a continuous process by which a
person changes his own behavior or tries to change the environment or brings
changes in both to produce satisfactory relationship with his environment
Adjustment therefore has been considered as an index to integration; a
harmonious behavior of the individual by which other individuals of the society
recognize the person as well adjusted (L Preeti and E. Arnold, 2012)5.
Coping during adolescence is therefore essential in the modern society as life
is becoming very complex and conflicting day by day. This trend is alarming and
therefore it is important that we pay attention to adolescent adjustment
processes.
With respect to adolescent adjustment, parental
warmth/involvement and behavioral control are associated with greater social
competence, autonomy, positive attitudes toward school and work, academic
achievement and self-esteem, as well as with less depression, school
misconduct, delinquency and drug use (Lamborn et al., 1996)6.
Therefore, the family plays a pivotal role in providing the most congenial
atmosphere in which the child forms his style of life and basic patterns of
behavior. Most of the children who are successful and well adjusted come from
homes where a wholesome relationship existed between them and their parents,
whereas children who were discouraged and rejected at home, lacked
concentration in school work (Bowlby, 1969)7. They failed to
establish desirable skills in academics and sports. Psychological control has
also been found to be negatively related to healthy functioning. Cohesion and
harmony in parent-adolescent interactions appear to be linked to relationships
that are more positive.
There is strong evidence to
suggest that family dysfunction during childhood can negatively influence later
life experiences and adjustment (Werner and Broida, 1991)8. Drinking
behavior may interrupt normal family tasks, cause conflict and demand adjustive
and adaptive responses from family members who do not know how to appropriately
respond. In brief, alcoholism or substance use creates a series of escalating
crises in family structure and function, which may bring the family to a system
crisis. As a result, the members may develop dysfunctional coping behaviours
observes Ranganathan (2004)9.
Signs of maladjustment among adolescence of substance
users:
Substance use and
dependence are among the most prevalent psychiatric disorders (Kesseler RC et
al 2005 and Kringlen E, Torgersen
S, Cramer V: 2001)10,11 also among parents
(Lieb R et al and Maloney E, Hutchinson D, Burns L, Mattick R)12, 13
. An extensive amount of research has been conducted on the psychological
functioning of children of alcohol abusers, although relatively few studies
have addressed these children’s school adjustment.
Parental alcohol abuse or
substance use is an independent risk factor for attention and conduct problems
at school, which is not fully mediated by adolescent mental distress. While the
association between parent-reported drinking and school adjustment seems to be
modest when alcohol abuse occurs without co morbid disorders, witnessing the
parents drunk was a stronger predictor for poor adjustment. The association
between school adjustment and both parents’ alcohol use seem to be mediated by
seeing the parents drunk. We cannot exclude that direct exposure to drunken
parents partially causes the problems. Maternal drinking may be worse for
children than paternal drinking, and maternal drinking may have an effect
partially mediated by adolescent mental distress. Only the externalizing
dimensions were associated with parental alcohol abuse. Despite more attention
and conduct problems, children of alcohol abusers enjoy school as much as other
children. ( Fartein A Torvik, 2011) 14.
Harter (2000)15
reports that Children of Alcholics faced difficulties in family relationships,
and experienced generalized distress and maladjustment. Hall and Webster (2002)16
found that Adult Children of Alcoholics had more symptoms of personal
dysfunction than the control group while Casas-Gil and Navarro-Guzman (2002)17
report that more COAs than comparison offspring were experiencing serious
problems in the areas of educational and social functioning. Sher et al (1991)18
observe that COAs also evidenced lower academic achievement and less verbal
ability than nCOAs. Lower quality of life scores in children of alcoholics has
been reported in another study by Oravecz (2002)19. Haugland (2003)20
also reports that children of alcohol abusing fathers were found to have more
adjustment problems compared to a general population sample. His findings
further suggested that child adjustment in families with paternal alcohol abuse
is the result of an accumulation of risk factors rather than the effects of the
paternal alcohol abuse alone. Both general environmental risk factors
(psychological problems in the fathers, family climate, family health and
conflicts) and environmental factors related to the parental alcohol abuse
(severity of the alcohol abuse, the child’s level of exposure to the alcohol
abuse, changes in routines and rituals due to drinking) were related to child
adjustment.
Prior research has found
that characteristics of the family (e.g., parental monitoring, parental
discipline, family conflict, family rituals) may mediate and/or moderate the
relationship between parental alcoholism and offspring adjustment (Sher, 1991;
Windle and Tubman, 1999)21, 22. However, it should be noted that the
majority of investigations that have examined characteristics of COA families
have examined the family at a family systems level.
Findings from this study
have important implications for prevention and intervention programs that
target offspring of alcoholic parents. First, these results suggest that it is
particularly critical to target children of alcoholic mothers, especially
daughters of alcoholic mothers. Results from this study also indicate that
programs should aim to teach these vulnerable youth to use more effective
coping strategies (e.g., instead of avoidance) when they are upset by their
parent’s drinking. The findings also suggest that prevention programs should target
ways to help girls from alcoholic families to become less emotionally
entrenched in their dysfunctional family system. Importantly, this study has
demonstrated the usefulness of adopting a micro-level approach when examining
the relationship between parental substance use and adolescent adjustment.
Researchers within the field should seriously consider taking a similar
approach since the more that we understand the underlying processes involved in
alcoholic families, the more that we will be able to help those who are
affected.
The Longitudinal associations between
fathers' heavy drinking patterns and children's psychosocial adjustment
results demonstrated significant and
meaningful associations between these drinking patterns in fathers and
adjustment problems in children over time. Overall, children whose fathers
remained mostly abstinent following their treatment showed lowest and
decreasing adjustment problems, while children whose fathers continued and
increased heavy drinking following their treatment showed greatest and
increasing adjustment problems over time. (Andreas JB and O'Farrell TJ, 2007)23
Interventions for adolescents of substance users:
Currently, many COAs remain
unidentified within schools and may not be receiving the counseling services
that they deserve and require. The family dysfunctionality of such children
places them at high risk for adverse academic, physiological, emotional, and
social consequences observe Lambie and Sias (2005)24. It then
becomes an important task for the school counsellor to identify such children
in distress and to provide them with supportive services besides intervention
with families to the extent possible. Knowledge of fathers’ alcohol use and its
time of onset may be used to determine children who are at added risk of
problematic alcohol use later in life and so special guidance, support and
treatment can be targeted to these families observe Seljamo et al (2006)25.
In the Indian scenario where the majority of schools do not have a professional
counsellor, this important task needs to be addressed by teachers who are in a
position to identify such children.
It is therefore important
that the therapeutic needs of these children are addressed through individual
psychotherapy and other supportive therapies by providing an opportunity for
ventilation of feelings and integrating elements that will boost their self
esteem and promote their psychosocial adjustment in deficient areas. Normal
difficulties and dilemmas associated with adolescence in general could be
worked through in these sessions besides focusing on issues pertaining to
parental alcoholism. A study from Korea reports that stress management program
helps children of alcoholics by enhancing self-esteem, providing information
about alcohol, and improving emotional and problem focused coping abilities,
eventually enhancing their mental health (Yang and Lee, 2005)26.
Hence stress management techniques and relaxation modalities could be an
important component of working with COAs.
Kuhns (1997)27
observes that both group psychotherapy and self-help groups for COAs were
effective in decreasing levels of depression while Kingree and Thompson (2000)28
found that participation in the mutual help group promoted perceived status
benefits, which in turn led to reductions in depression and substance use. The
need to strengthen the social support available to such children has been
highlighted by Werner and Johnson (2004)29 whose data showed that
individuals who coped effectively with the trauma of growing up in an alcoholic
family and who became competent adults relied on a significantly larger number
of sources of support in their childhood and youth than did the offspring of
alcoholics with coping problems. Intervention with COAs must hence involve
resolution of individualised issues pertaining to adolescence as well as
parental alcoholism. Elements to enhance their self esteem and adjustment
across various domains need to be consciously included besides involving them
in family therapy sessions. Strengthening their social support systems,
fortifying familial bonds besides facilitating their participation in self help
groups comprising of other COAs, could go a long way in enhancing their mental
health. Christine MO., Victor MH.,
Kyrianna R, and John K.(2006)30 These efforts must be
concurrently initiated along with other therapeutic procedures that focus on
the alcoholic per se.
CONCLUSION:
Parental
alcohol use damages and disrupts the lives of countless children and families
in all areas of society, spanning all social classes. It blights the lives of
whole families and harms the development of children trapped by the effects of
their parents problematic drinking. It is time to take the next step and
prioritize support in order to meet the specific needs of children of substance
using parents, as well as providing support directly to parents themselves.
REFERENCES:
1.
Gehlawat M. A Study of Adjustment among High School Students In Relation
to Their Gender International Referred Research Journal, October, 2011.; VoL.III
.
2.
Anon. (2004).
Wingspread declaration on school connections. Journal of School Health;74:
233–234.
3.
Gonzales-Pienda,
JA, Nunez JC, Gonzalez-Pumariega S, Alvarez L, Roces C, and Garcia M (2002). A
structural equation model of parental involvement, motivational and altitudinal
characteristics, and academic achievement. The Journal of Experimental
Education; 70:257-287.
4.
Duncan MH.(1949).
Home adjustment of stutterers and non-stutterers. Journal of Speech and Hearing
Disorders; 14: 225-259.
5.
Preeti L and Arnold E. (2012) Adolescent adjustment in high school students: a brief report on
mid-adolescence transitioning GESJ: Education Science and
Psychology No.3 (22) ,Arnold Emerson 1VIT University, School
of Social Sciences and Languages, India
6.
Lamborn S D and
Steinberg L. (1996). Emotional autonomy redux: Revisiting Ryan and Lynch. Child
Development;64:483-499.
7.
Bowlby J. (1969).
Attachment and loss: Attachment, 1, New York: Basic.
8.
Werner L J. and
Broida J P. (1991) Adult self-esteem and locus of control as a function of
familial alcoholism and dysfunction.Journal of Studies on Alcohol; 52:249-252.
9.
Ranganathan S.
(2004) Families in Transition: Victims of Alcoholism and New Challenges Ahead.
International Journal for the Advancement of Counselling; 26:399-405.
10. Kessler RC, Chiu WT, Demler O, Merikangas KR, Walters
EE.(2005) Prevalence, severity, and comorbidity of 12-month DSM-IV disorders in
the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Arch Gen Psychiatry ; 62:617-627.
11. Kringlen E,
Torgersen S, Cramer V. (2001). A Norwegian psychiatric epidemiological study.
Am J Psychiatry; 158:1091-1098
12. Lieb R, Merikangas KR, Hofler M, Pfister H, Isensee B,
Wittchen HU. (2002) Parental alcohol use disorders and alcohol use and
disorders in offspring: a community study. Psychol Med; 32:63-78.
13. Maloney E, Hutchinson D, Burns L, Mattick R.(2010)
Prevalence and patterns of problematic alcohol use among Australian parents.
Aust N Z J Public Health ; 34:495-501.
14. Fartein AT, Kamilla R, Helga A, Espen R and K T et al.
(2011) Parental alcohol use and adolescent school adjustment in the general
population: Results from the HUNT study. BMC Public Health; 11:706
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/706
15. Harter SL. (2000) Psychosocial adjustment of adult
children of alcoholics: a review of the recent empirical literature. Clinical
Psychological Review;20:311-337.
16. Hall CW and Webster RE. (2002). Traumatic
symptomatology characteristics of adult children of alcoholics. Journal of Drug
Education;32:195-211.
17. Casas-Gil MJ and Navarro-Guzman JI. (2002) School
characteristics among children of alcoholic parents. Psychological Reports;
90:341-348.
18. Sher KJ., Walitzer KS., Wood PK., et al (1991)
Characteristics of children of alcoholics: putative risk factors, substance use
and abuse, and psychopathology. Journal of Abnormal Psychology;100: 427-448.
19. Oravecz R. (2002) Children of alcoholics. Horizons of
Psychology; 11 (3): 95-107.
20. Haugland BS. (2003) Paternal alcohol abuse:
relationship between child adjustment, parental characteristics, and family functioning.
Child Psychiatry and Human Development;34:127-46.
21. Sher K J. (1991). Children of Alcoholics: A Critical Appraisal of Theory and Research. Chicago:
University of Chicago Press.
22. Windle M, and Tubman JG. (1999). Children of
alcoholics. In W.K. Silverman, and T.H. Ollendick (Eds.), Developmental Issues in the Clinical
Treatment of Children; Boston: Allyn and Bacon:393–414
23. Andreas JB, O'Farrell
TJ.(2007) Longitudinal associations between fathers' heavy drinking patterns
and children's psychosocial adjustment. Journal of abnormal child psychology; 35:1-16
24. Lambie, D. M. and Sias, S. M. (2005) Children of
Alcoholics: Implications for Professional School Counselling. Professional
School Counselling, Special issue: Professional School Counselling in Urban Settings;
8:266-273.
25. Seljamo, S., Aromaa, M., Koivusilta, L., et al (2006)
Alcohol use in families: A 15-year prospective follow-up study. Addiction; 101:
984-992.
26. Yang SH. and Lee PS. (2005) The effects of a stress
management program on mental health and the coping behavior for the children of
alcoholics. Taehan Kanho Hakhoe Chi; 35: 77-86.
27. Kuhns, M.L. (1997) Treatment outcomes with adult
children of alcoholics: depression. Advanced Practice of Nursing Quarterly; 3:
64-69.
28. Kingree, J.B. and Thompson, M. (2000) Mutual help
groups, perceived status benefits, and well-being: a test with adult children
of alcoholics with personal substance abuse problems. American Journal of
Community Psychology; 28: 325-342.
29. Werner, E.E. and Johnson, J.L. (2004) The role of caring
adults in the lives of children of alcoholics. Substance Use and Misuse; 39:
699-720.
30.
Christine MO., Victor MH., Kyrianna R, and John K.(2006) Parental
Substance Use and Adolescent Adjustment: A Micro-Level Approach By. www.TPRonline.org .The Prevention Researcher; 13 (4) .
Received on 09.08.2015 Modified
on 24.08.2015
Accepted on 05.09.2015 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Int. J. Nur. Edu. and Research 3(4):
Oct.-Dec., 2015; Page 428-432
DOI: 10.5958/2454-2660.2015.00036.8